ALA Annual 2026

#ALAAC26: Private Discovery by Design for Young People

Young people often come to libraries with partial answers already in hand. Search results, social feeds, and conversational AI systems may have shaped the answers they bring. Private discovery asks how much a young person must reveal before reaching help.

Amanda Gray Perry of the University of Notre Dame moderated Core’s Top Tech Trends panel. Speakers working in public libraries, academic libraries, and library technology examined AI, metadata infrastructure, discovery tools, and media access. In my presentation, “Private Discovery by Design: AI Infrastructure in Teen Services,” I posed the question directly: When does a teen’s inquiry become data?

Values Before Tools

Nicole Steeves, Director of Library Technology at Chicago Public Library, set out a values-based approach to AI. She argued for AI investment when a proposed use improves patron service, protects privacy, preserves staff expertise, and includes human review. She drew clear limits around reference search, readers’ advisory, and traditional catalog search. Library judgment remains difficult to automate. She cautioned against entering personally identifiable information, personal health information, or criminal justice information into AI tools. The warning set a practical boundary for library service.

For children’s, family, and teen services, a values-based approach helps staff avoid unexamined adoption and blanket refusal. Hype risks pushing new applications into service before staff have examined privacy, accuracy, or developmental fit. Reflexive avoidance risks blocking a use with real value for language support, disability access, or staff capacity. Staff can ask which patron need the tool meets and what the tool asks from the patron in return.

When Inquiry Becomes Data

I defined private discovery as a young person’s ability to search, browse, ask, and encounter information. Private discovery avoids unnecessary disclosure, profiling, reporting, or exposure.

Teen inquiry often involves identity, safety, and belonging. A young person may look for information about anxiety, grief, sexuality, gender identity, religion, family tension, abuse, or a controversial book. The young person may not be ready to speak the need aloud.

At Montgomery County Public Libraries, our Teen Tough Topics resource creates a lower-disclosure path for sensitive browsing. Teen Tough Topics gathers subjects, shelf locations, catalog paths, and librarian help. A teen can find an initial route without explaining the need first.

Forms and prompts set privacy terms before staff respond. A reading preference form, program registration field, online reference box, survey comment, or AI prompt can create a record. Lower-data service asks for less, explains purpose, limits retention, and keeps surveys optional when possible. The same approach protects sensitive questions from unnecessary reporting or third-party platforms.

Prompt Privacy

AI literacy for teens should include prompt privacy. AI chat interfaces may process or retain user language in ways young people do not see. Teens need strategies for generalizing personal questions, removing identifying details, and asking for search terms or next steps. Verification belongs with library resources and human expertise.

During Q&A, an audience question about AI education across ages moved the conversation from tools to capacity. Steeves named staff training and partnerships with schools and community organizations. Erica Acevedo, Bilingual Adult and Teen Services Specialist at Fox River Valley Public Library District, discussed public classes with privacy and appropriate use built into instruction. I pointed to partnerships as a workable route when local capacity is limited. AI literacy programming should teach tool use. Strong instruction gives young people ways to protect personal language before entering a question into a system.

Low-Data Browsing

Physical browsing remains one of libraries’ lowest-data discovery paths. A face-out book, display, booklist, shelf talker, passive readers’ advisory tool, or teen recommendation card offers a lower-data route. The route requires no login, prompt, profile, or spoken disclosure. Sensitive discovery areas call for low-disclosure pathways. The shelf gives a young person time to notice, consider, and choose a next step before asking an adult for help.

Local Fit and Changing Access Routes

Marshall Breeding, independent consultant and editor of Library Technology Guides, described a web environment shaped by conversational systems. Users increasingly begin with chat interfaces instead of Google, library websites, or catalogs. Information seeking can happen outside library-controlled interfaces. Young people may receive answers without seeing cataloging decisions, metadata structures, or source pathways.

Rebekah Silverstein, Digital Services Librarian at Oklahoma State University, used textbook access reporting to show the value of metadata and controlled vocabulary. Her example connected data organization, findings, and impact claims. Acevedo discussed cloud gaming and the access challenges created by subscriptions, streaming, and remote computing. As platforms move away from physical media, libraries may need to redesign access routes.

During Q&A, a vendor asked how companies should balance AI-assisted technologies with staff expertise and understaffed-library realities. My response cautioned against a single AI product model for every library type. Public, academic, school, and special libraries have different staffing realities, policies, risk tolerances, and patron needs. Smaller applications or interfaces with one well-defined purpose often serve libraries better than large systems promising to solve everything.

A Service Design Test

My service design test asks:

  • What brings the young person to the service?
  • What must the young person disclose?
  • What record gets created or reused?
  • Who or what can access the record?
  • Which lower-data path could work?
  • Where should human judgment interrupt an automated workflow?

Private discovery is a service principle before it is a product feature. Young people should be able to search, browse, ask, and explore without unnecessary disclosure, profiling, or retention of their inquiry.

Intellectual freedom depends on resources, routes, and privacy at the point of access. AI and other platforms will keep shaping discovery in libraries. Library workers serving children and teens carry a human responsibility. Our task is to design pathways for young people to reach information without recording more of themselves than the service requires.


Witt Salley (he/him/his) is the Teen Services Librarian at Quince Orchard Library in Montgomery County Public Libraries. At ALA Annual 2026, he looks forward to conversations about accessibility, AI literacy, teen services, and DigitalLearn’s next chapter for public libraries. He will be one of the presenters for “PLA Update on Apple Accessibility Toolkits for Libraries” and will speak on “Private Discovery by Design: AI Infrastructure in Teen Services” as part of Core’s Top Tech Trends panel. If he could read one book again for the first time, he would choose Ellen Raskin’s The Westing Game for the way it turns attention, pattern-finding, and community into a shared act of discovery.


Please note that, as a guest post, this content does not represent the official position of ALA or ALSC.

If you are interested in submitting a guest post, please read and fill out our Guest Blogging Interest Form. We would love to hear from you!

One comment

  1. Laiba

    Interesting discussion on designing digital discovery around the needs of young people. AI chatbot development can create more accessible and conversational ways to help users find relevant information while keeping the experience intuitive and engaging.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *