We’ve all been there. You spend weeks planning what feels like the perfect children’s program. You prepare thoughtful activities, gather materials, and add creative touches. Then… only a handful of kids show up. It can feel disappointing and frustrating. But low attendance is something every youth services librarian faces at some point. Instead of letting those moments get us down, what if we saw them as chances to rethink what success really means?
The Pressure of the “Perfect Program”
It’s easy to get caught up chasing the perfect program—one that fills the room and wows the crowd. The desire to showcase bustling, successful programs often comes from passion and pride. But it can also create pressure that overshadows our true purpose. When we judge ourselves only by how many chairs are filled, we lose sight of what really matters. The deeper connections and meaningful moments often happen quietly, in smaller groups.
Beyond Numbers: Redefining Success
What if success wasn’t just about attendance? Some of my favorite moments happened at programs where only a few kids showed up. Like the afternoon just three siblings came to Enchanted Tales. We ended up inviting their grownups to help play a parachute game. Or the day only three kids came to STEM: Build Your Own Board Game. They had the freedom to ask tons of questions and come up with wild ideas.
Then there was the messy art program. Afterward, a parent told me it was the first time her usually anxious child felt brave enough to join in. Moments like that don’t show up in reports—but they mean everything. They’re what keep us going: making kids feel welcome, sparking curiosity, and building trust.
When attendance is unpredictable, flexibility becomes our superpower. It might mean cutting a craft to fit five kids instead of twenty. It could mean turning a big group game into a small circle. Or simply letting the kids who are there help shape what we do.
Embracing Flexibility
One summer day, I planned a big Recess Games program—but only five kids came. So instead, we had them each teach the group their favorite recess game, and it turned into something special none of us had planned. Being able to pivot keeps things relaxed and fun—and it shows kids that it’s okay when plans change.
It’s normal to feel a little let down when only a few people come, especially after all the prep and excitement. Talking about it openly with coworkers, and sharing both the tough days and the unexpected happy moments, helps us keep perspective and remember we’re not alone.
Building Resilience—for Staff and Services
As a team or library, it helps to celebrate trying new things—even if they don’t pack the room—and to focus on process, creativity, and what we learn along the way. Because programming isn’t just about numbers—it’s about connecting with kids and families and figuring out what really matters to them.
When we focus on flexibility and resilience, our programs stay welcoming and responsive, even as our communities keep changing. And for us as librarians, it makes the work feel lighter, more creative, and more joyful—even on the days attendance surprises us.
The Long View: Why It Matters
Low attendance isn’t failure—it’s part of library life. Every program, whether it’s crowded or cozy, is a chance to talk with a child about their day, share a laugh, or see someone open up for the first time. At the end of the day, we don’t plan programs just to fill chairs—we do it for the kids and families who come through our doors, however many that may be.
Jessica Tarnowski(she/her/hers) is a Youth Services Librarian at the Bartlett Public Library District in Bartlett, Illinois. She is dedicated to developing creative and immersive programs that spark curiosity and joy among children.
Uma Nori
Great post Jessica!
Couple days ago I read Brandy Sanchez’s newsletter recommending the book “The Gap and The Gain: The High Achievers Guide to Happiness, Confidence, and Success” by Dan Sullivan and Dr. Benjamin Hardy.
Your post on urging us to rethink what success really means is valuable and resonated with some of the things mentioned in this book for me.
Thanks!
Jessica Tarnowski
Thank you so much! I’ve not heard of The Gap and The Gain —it sounds like it ties in beautifully with this conversation. I’ve added it to my list. Appreciate you making that connection!
Antonieta Ortega
Hello! I completely agreed with the concept. recently I conducted a program for elementary aged students, to learn how to make a friendship beaded safety pin. I waited for the first 5 minutes, and I had one participant showing up, we started the craft and latter on I learned through casual conversation that she was about to start middle school, and she was a bit nervous, then she talks about her pets at home. we spent the entire hour engaging on conversation and the craft, she promises to invite more friends to the next. program and she was so happy and proud of her craft. we had such a great connection.
Jessica Tarnowski
This is wonderful—what a great example of turning a small program into a big success. Those conversations and connections are what kids will remember most.