Children's Literature (all forms)

Reading for the Mock Awards

by Teresa Walls

Last week I attended the Allen County (IN) Public Library’s Mock Sibert Event. It is one of five mock award programs held at the Allen County Public Library . The others are a Mock Caldecott, a Mock Geisel, a Mock Newbery and a Mock Printz. While I’m excited to hear what the real committees select for the real awards, I’m even more excited to start reading the newly published books which will be eligible for the 2010 awards.

We learn a great deal through our discussion of the literary merits of the books we have loved or hated, but the true reward of participating in these programs is keeping up with the new books in order to offer thoughtful reader’s advisory for our patrons. The mock award programs push me to read many books I would not have picked up on my own. For that reason, I strongly encourage more of you to consider hosting or participating in a mock Sibert. The Robert F. Sibert Informational Book Award was established in 2001.

As a reader, I always head to the shelves of fiction and poetry. As a librarian, I have an excellent understanding of classification systems, Boolean and keyword searches, but many exceptional informational works are available that I might have missed sharing with the right reader if I hadn’t participated in the Mock Sibert. The adage “so many books, so little time” is so true. If it weren’t for the Mock Sibert, I would spend too little of my free reading time with informational books. Not only do I learn a great deal, but every year I find myself leading a patron to one or more of our Mock Sibert books during a reference interview. Perhaps I would have found those books via my searching skills, but I would have missed that feeling of a fellow reader sharing a great book.


  1. Heather

    I completely agree. Reading for the Mock Sibert keeps me in touch with new non-fiction that I would not pick up on my own. I regularly refer to the old ACPL Mock Sibert reading lists to answer reference questions when I can’t quite remember that great title that I read about birds…

  2. Teresa Walls Post author

    Thanks, Heather, for mentioning the previous ACPL Mock Sibert reading lists. I too have found them to be a wonderful reference tool.

  3. James Preller

    Nicely done. I’m a big fan of transparency, pulling back the curtain. And I wholly agree about awards in general: It’s not so much “winners” and (therefore) “losers,” but a matter of celebrating all the work we love, and respect, and value. Thanks for being such a dedicated book lover: A READER!


  4. Natz

    I love being seen for my good work and achievement, nobody wants to lose for some reason. Share your good things and be always a book lover. We start to learn when we start to read.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *